The lament of a lone Bollywood lover

Publié le 10 Juin 2007

I’m sure you BW fans in the four corners of the world have had a similar experience: uneasy admittance of that shameful addiction: Bollywood obsession! You know, it starts like a dream, a nice dinner party with friends at your place, or at the restaurant, and the conversation lags a little, or people ask you what is your hobby, or revolves around cinema, while just before that, you were wondering how ON EARTH you were going to able to have people speak about Bollywood, so much as to say: about you, about what you love, and are so knowledgeable about! Well, it continues as a dream: they do it! They DON’T KNOW your craze, and they ask you what you do in your spare time, or what kind of films you like watching, or even more WOW: some cherishable person actually starts warbling about an Indian film he’s just seen on TV!

 

You then “reluctantly” admit that yes, you’re a fan too, or something of the sort, but inwardly you exult: you’re sharing that passion of yours once again!! You can vibrate with whoever it is who has liked SRK, Abhishek, or AR Rahman’s songs, and of course you can drop the names nicely, authoritatively… You can demur when somebody mentions silly remakes, because the originals were so much better, and blah blah blah. Then the not-so good part starts: you try to avoid your partner’s gaze, he or she who knows everything concerning that fad of yours, and perhaps doesn’t share it, and who has already tried to explain to you that OTHER films exist in the world; you also have to confront that nagging impression that, past the first moments of interest, your passion is not regarded as so very important by your listeners. They listen politely at first, but as soon as you go deeper into the differences between Kollywood and Lollywood, or something as inane, you see their eyes looking elsewhere as if to find some other people already involved in another discussion. There you are, you are now reduced to the not very enviable status of Bollywood weirdo.

 

And you long to be left to those dear blogs and forums where you can splash thigh-high in your passion, your life, your dream. Or of course, watch that dear film that you’ve just bought and that has been quietly waiting for you to lift it gently in your hands and drop it as gently in your DVD drive. And when you’re there, finally doing that, it’s that dear bliss and rapture. But, I am now going to ask: why all this? Why this fad? How long is it going to last? How come I’m so alone with this? I know I’m not crazy, but do I know whether I’m “doing the right thing”? Shouldn’t I be looking after my children and family more? My cultural universe isn’t connected with India and Indian cinema. I’m a geek, a weirdo. All this Hindi I’m learning, which pleases me so much, why, kyu? I do hope one day (ek din) to go there, to see this world I’m plunged in through this deforming lens of Indian cinema, and which I must correct thanks to other sources of information. But why India? Why not Brazil? Why not Vanuatu??

 

So here I am, struggling with my justifications, explaining my quirkiness, like the other day at work, when a little book about Hinduism (“Hinduism, a very short Introduction”, by Kim Knott) fell out of my pocket, and a colleague asked me “Ah, Hinduism?” and I found myself saying, “yes, I’m a fascinated by all that.”. Not very noteworthy, of course; everybody has a right to read books about Hinduism. But this colleague had already, not so long ago, seen me with a teach-yourself Hindi manual (“Hindi express”, by Aparna Kshirsagar & Jean Jacquement), and has already commented on it, and so this second discovery bared me in front of him as a kind of monomaniac which I tried to masquerade as passion. Perhaps it worked for him. But for me? I can’t hide from myself the doubts that I have about the unconscious reasons of my addiction. What’s gotten hold of me? Why has this culturally so distant world of art and life taken such an importance in my life? I find myself hiding the films which I receive through the mail, and congratulating myself when I am the first to open the mailbox and spirit the brown package out of sight. I have this huge box of films in my study, and my children admit it’s my hobby while wondering why the films have to remain in that box, out of the normal family circuit?

 

Well, there you have it. The musings of a lonely Bollywood fan. Hmm… Does this mean I’m on the downhill slope towards a normalisation of my passion and that it’s burning itself out? I s'pose the future will tell.

Rédigé par yves

Publié dans #Bollywood Talk

Commenter cet article

amal 01/09/2012 20:17


bonjour ici amal, de l'ile maurice ( mais je vis en ce moment a madagascar) je suis d'origine indienne et j'ai grandi dans l'atmosphere de bollywood. ces films peuvent effectivement etre tres
prenants, par leurs chansons, leur intensite emotionelle souvent explosive.  personnellement je suis surtout fan de certaines chansons des annees 50 par des chanteurs comme mukesh and
mohammad rafi. mais j'avoue que j'ai ete accroche comme vous par le film "dil se" de mani ratnam. c'est tres addictif ! je sympathise beaucoup avec votre solitude, car il est sur que la culture
francaise est beaucoup eprise du classicisme, du minimalisme, dans ses diverses formes d'expression. hier meme, je parlais a un ecrivain malgache tres francophile, a propos du manuscrit de son
roman, et je lui suggerais d'ajouter quelques ficelles pour corser un peu l'intrigue, mais il trouve que ce serait grossier, car il veut que tout le roman soit base sur une "atmosphere". on
retrouve aussi ce souci "d'atmosphere" dans tant de films francais. le realisateur dedaigne tout ce qui tiendrait du suspense ou de l'emotion, pour creer un tableau "d'une atmosphere" ( d'ou tous
ces films si lents, avec depardieu et catherine deneuve). enfin, je ne veux pas trop critiquer votre culture, je veux simplement qu'elle est tres axee sur un effet esthetique qui tient presque du
stoicisme, dans sa retenue. dans un tel contexte, j'imagine qu'il doit etre tres difficile pour vous de trouver des ames soeurs... en passant permettez moi de vous feliciter pour votre anglais,
qui est d'une subtilite admirable. cordialement   amal

yves 02/09/2012 10:49



Bonjour Amal,


Quel plaisir de lire votre long message! Vous avez raison sur les difficultés du cinéma français à se sortir d'un certain style, même si des réalisations comme Intouchables récemment (ou d'autres
comme La môme) peuvent permettre d'espérer que des innovations vers du cinéma grand public qui sera apprécié internationalement verront le jour.


Ma difficulté de trouver des âmes soeurs est plus grande en France pour trouver des amateurs de cinéma indien avec qui partager; c'est vrai que, puisque j'ai choisi de faire ce blog en anglais,
j'ai forcément moins de contacts avec des francophones, mais quand même! Alors je me console avec les contacts des amateurs de langue anglaise, sauf vous! Donc merci encore, et n'hésitez pas à
revenir: vous voyez que depuis Dil se, j'ai pas mal bougé!



Nirvana 22/10/2007 13:56

i think one good reason for loving BW is because everytime u watch a good BW movie, you are undergoing a catharsis. You plunge into some deep emotions that you would not approach otherwise. U watch a movie and u live a pseudo-live that u are falling short-of in real life. You never get that in Hollywood films. They leave u with a sense of incompleteness.But dont worry u are in good company. After all 1 billion Indians (watching all the 'ollywoods) cant be wrong.

Alan 07/07/2007 19:21

Good post.  I can relate to all of it. In answer to "But why India?"   The girls!

yves 08/07/2007 23:38

Hi Alan,Thanks for dropping by. "The girls"... Yes, that's what hooked me on BW first too, but don't you think we've been trapped because of the Bollywood PR system: who knows if the Vanuatu girls aren't as gorgeous?Cheersyves